Epinions.com 
Join Epinions | Learn More! | Sign In   
Home > Message Boards > Books > Writing Book Reviews > Auto-reviewing

Auto-reviewing
Posts on this Topic   Search in Writing Book Reviews   
Showing 1-12 of 12 posts      
Show member images Print     Start a new topic     Post a Reply
   
dolphinboy Original Post: Nov 30 '08,  1:00 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 529
Member since: Apr 15 '06
Post: 210989
Auto-reviewing

Some sites allow authors to review their own books, either listed as any other review, or given a special section. Other sites prohibit or discourage this.

What think you?

   
panguitch Posted: Dec 02 '08,  8:16 am           Reply
Reviews written: 285
Member since: Jul 30 '02
moderator in Books, Magazines & Newspapers
Post: 211149
RE: Auto-reviewing

I rate as Off-Topic any "review" an author writes themselves.

By definition you cannot review your own work. Such a "review" would not be a review at all, and so should not be posted in the reviews section of the site. It should instead be posted in the writer's corner.

-Andy

   
quasar Posted: Dec 02 '08,  10:43 am           Reply
Reviews written: 1937
Member since: Jan 16 '00
Post: 211165
RE: Auto-reviewing

I give it a not helpful as the point of a review is unbiased commentary and recommendation and the author of a book always has a vested interest in encouraging people to buy it.

   
jsgoddess Posted: Dec 02 '08,  12:11 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 140
Member since: Apr 06 '00
moderator in Books, Magazines & Newspapers
Post: 211171
RE: Auto-reviewing

Not helpful, in my opinion. It's just an ad rather than a review.

Julie

   
kevintipple Posted: Dec 20 '08,  4:48 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 587
Member since: Jul 31 '02
Post: 212593
Re: Auto Reviewing

is writing a press release or an ad. If you wrote the book, you certainly can't review it. Nor, as in my case, the published book contains one story of yours and half a dozen from other folks.

Reviewing your own book simply isn't done here or in the real world beyond Epinions. I always rate those that try as NH and encourage others to do so. It also pretty much kills any credibility you did have review wise before you reviewed your own book.

Kevin

   
celina12 Posted: Jul 30 '09,  9:12 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 0
Member since: Jul 30 '09
Post: 231949
comment

This is a wonderful opinion. The things mentioned are unanimous and needs to be appreciated by everyone.
Harley Davidson

   
pestyside Posted: Jul 31 '09,  10:41 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 1059
Member since: Jul 19 '05
Post: 232043
RE: Auto-reviewing

Quote: jsgoddess
Not helpful, in my opinion. It's just an ad rather than a review.

Julie


It's more a summary although that can depend on how it's written. Some sites allow a publisher's note to be included with the description, some allow an interview of the author (which I actually enjoy), but Epinions doesn't really offer either format. Honestly, I don't know a single author who's going to say anything negative about their book -- even if they are their own harshest critic.

patsy
   
carstairs38 Posted: Aug 25 '09,  2:26 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 1209
Member since: Oct 03 '05
Post: 234427
RE: Auto-reviewing

Not Helpful and block.

Thanks for playing.

Mark

   
phungus Posted: Sep 07 '09,  10:12 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 2313
Member since: Aug 31 '99
Post: 235887
RE: Auto-reviewing

I might let it slide if it were an Express Review, but otherwise a full 'review' would really just be spam.

   
kevintipple Posted: Sep 12 '09,  1:16 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 587
Member since: Jul 31 '02
Post: 236342
RE: Auto-reviewing

I would not let it slide in express either.

   
sleeper54 Posted: Sep 12 '09,  3:31 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 496
Member since: Feb 24 '01
Post: 236344
RE: Auto-reviewing

Quote: kevintipple
I would not let it slide in express either.

me needer...



...tom...
.
   
pestyside Posted: Sep 14 '09,  8:45 am           Reply
Reviews written: 1059
Member since: Jul 19 '05
Post: 236479
RE: Auto-reviewing

Not even in an Express review -- sorry.

patsy

Show member images Print     Start a new topic     Post a Reply
Showing 1-12 of 12 posts      
Return to top

Help | Member Center | Message Boards | Site Rules | User Agreement | Privacy Policy | Site Index | Topic Index  
About Epinions | Careers | Contact Epinions | Advertising  

Epinions | Shopping.com | Rent.com | Free Classifieds | Price Comparison UK

Shopping.com Network © 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc. Trademark Notice

Epinions.com periodically updates pricing and product information from third-party sources,
so some information may be slightly out-of-date. You should confirm all information before relying on it.