Black Is Beautiful...But The Price Is Grand!
Written: Sep 19 '07 (Updated Sep 28 '07)
|
Product Rating:
|
|
|
Pros: Good value! Low price! Tops in its class!
Cons: Some sibilants will be mistracked. Possible "Hum" problems in some systems.
The Bottom Line: At its price...the Grado Black is tough to beat! Currently...it cannot! Nothing else even comes close!
|
|
|
| sam-pro's Full Review: Grado Black Phono Cartridge P-Mount |
Preample:
Joseph Grado is a legend amongst turntablers. When his nephew...John Grado resumed the business of making quality phono cartridges in the late 90's, it did not take long for the experts to provide major accolades about the new entry level "Prestige" series. I initially felt that some of the praise was not deserved while a portion of it was.
I certainly loved the idea of this Brooklyn based family business manufacturing products here in the good 'ole U.S.A. But what I couldn't understand was the fact that my low cost Shures outperformed the low cost Grados and were much less susceptible to the dreaded "Hum" Grados were infamous for when used in certain Dual 1200 Series and Rega "P" series tables when used with basic receivers and integrated amps.
However...recently I decided to give Grado another go-around after purchasing some new low cost audiophile-geared stereo separates including the lovely sounding TCC TC-760LC dedicated phono preamp that cost me all of $80! The new system which features an Audiosource Amp 100 power amp and Polk R-30 loudspeakers must be considered to be the all-time bargain basement best!
The "Prestige" line of IM phono cartridges includes six models...Platinum, Gold, Red, Blue, Green and finally the lowly Black. These are available in either "S" Standard Mount or "P" P-Mount T4P plug-in models.
As Grado Labs products are legitimately available only from your local high end dealer...then it only follows and should come at no surprise that this particular P-mount pickup was picked up and paid for in full by yours truly on the fourth of September, 2007 at Audio Connection of Verona, NJ...the highest of high end salons. Please see the link on my home page.
Grado Prestige Black Specs:
Frequency Response 10-50
Principal MI
Channel Separation at 1KHz 30
Imput Load 47K
Output at 1KHz 5CM/sec. 5mV
Recommended Tracking Force 1.5
Stylus Type E
Inductance 45mH
Resistance 475
Compliance CUs 20
Stylus Replacement U=user U
Mounting S/P
Weight 5.5g {6.0g for p-mount model}
The Candy Store:
The Grado Prestige Black P-Mount arrives to you in a plain white box with orange and black trim along with the famous Grado logo that has been embraced by High End audiophiles for quite some time now. This basic box is still so cool after so many years! So purchasing this pickup from John Rutan's Audio Connection Of Verona, NJ for a Technics SL-D30 Direct Drive turntable that until recently had been dormant for almost twenty years proved to be both quite alotta fun and rewarding.
First...John as usual gave me a great price on this $40 MSRP cartridge and associate Mary provided the item and necessary sales slip. Let me put it to you like this...whatever you think you can get a competing audio-technica A-T 92ECD for...John's price on the Grado Black P will pretty much match it.
Not only that but John's staff will treat you like Gold...no matter how much or how little you spend in his store. I've personally known this for over twenty years now. That's the way it should be. Unfortunately, other proprietors seem to think not. They prefer to embrace their pocket-filled clientelle whilst belittling those of limited cash flow. I just don't get it. Or perhaps even more sadly...I really do!
One side note I must tell you is that John wouldn't let me out of the store 'til I heard the updated version of his pet speaker system...a pair of Vandersteen Signature 2Ce's with the new midrange driver that is featured in the model Three. Once I heard the new improved model...I then understood the reason for my friend's huge kid-like grin. Paired to an Audio Research tube amp all I can say is...Hokey smokes, Bullwinkle! The Ventures never sounded so good and oh, those Mids!
Easy Setup:
But enough of my sidetracking {hey...better than mistracking!}. We're here to discuss the Grado Black P which sports that same cylindrical clear plastic container that provides home for cartridge w/stylus protector, a special tuning fork-like stylus extraction tool and instructions along with the updated classic warranty card. The product can also be registered at www.gradolabs.com as I did. It's quick and painless plus you get to keep your Grado Labs 1 year warranty card as a record of purchase and if nothing else...a wonderful souveneir.
Grado uses OFC {Oxygen Free Copper} internally in the cartridge's windings. This is most important as most of you know how I feel about the use of OFC. It can truly make for an audible difference that significantly improves both high frequencies and low ones...not to mention the all important midrange. Those carts without it are not worth hanging on to. Forget your old cartridge and buy a new one with this technology...like the Grado!
Using the original Technics side screw was simple and a must as Grado does not supply one with the unit. The cart butted up nicely to the P-Mount receptacle on the arm and VTA was near perfect in both front-to-back and side-to-side viewing by the naked eye. As Grado believes this is important for optimum performance...Technics SL-D30 owners need not concern themselves with any further adjustments in this regard.
However...you will need to adjust the VTF {Vertical Tracking Force} via the rear knob on the arm to 1.5 grams for optimum performance. Anti-skating compensation should also equal this setting. Grado loves that 1.5 gram setting but unfortunately Technics setup the P-Mount system to work at 1.25 grams. Luckily...the SL-D30 model provides for some but limited adjustment. I like Grado's force better as it gives the arm a better feel while still providing feather light tracking.
If you own one of the Technics "SLB" belt driven versions of this table, you can still increase the factory set VTF by turning the rear screw on the tonearm's counter balance weight. Carefully peel off the black label that states anti-skating is factory set at the base of the arm and it will reveal a small port that exposes the anti-skate adjusting screw.
You can use the smooth lead out area of one of your shorter LP's to visually compensate or breakout that old Shure Era V test record with the track that features buzzing in both channels. The first level you notice the raspiness in one channel is the one you want to use to make the adjustment. It is not necessary to go to the top level when the initial raspiness is noted in a lower one.
VTF can be checked with an inexpensive Shure SFG-2 Stylus Force Guage. On the SL-D30 the gauge will confirm the 1.5 gram setting.
Initiation:
The first two hours of break-in featured my favorite test and break-in record in the whole world...Reference Recordings "Professor Johnson's Astounding Sound Show" Cat# RR-7. Side One features some amazing and dynamic stuff that is also entertaining. Transients, musical timbres and dynamics are all in abundance and the Grado darn near aced the entire side except for ever so slightly less than perfect reproduction of bells and cymbals {Side One Tracks 2&3}. Just a wee bit of sandpaper and clanging were detected but it must be said that only cartridges of the highest quality at considerably much higher price tags than the Grado can ace this test. Some of the higher priced stuff can't match the Grado!
Now it must be said that the Technics SL-D30 is a classic Direct Drive hybrid. Unfortunately...because of that fact more than a few of you might think it to be one of those direct drive turntables noted by various audiophiles to have that metallicy bright resonant tonal quality and indeed my Stanton L720EE, A-T 3482P and 92ECD do indeed exhibit some brilliance in the SL-D30.
My personal view is that this has to do more with the plinth and even more so...the low mass tonearm. I do not believe that belt drive units are better or worse in general even though the vast majority of my thirty tables were in fact belt driven.
The SL-D30 also sports a pitch control. I really don't like these variable controls in general because I find myself constantly adjusting them to perfection before commencing each and every record play. I love the out-of- sight...out-of-mind feature of those that are factory set. Plus they must be maintained periodically and even replaced in some cases. Yet three of my four tables have them! Remember...these tt's were pretty much handed over to me on a silver platter...like the Technics...no pun intended {yes, there is}!
Please keep in mind that the tables in question do so very much sound and time wonderfully and were saved by yours truly from the threat of the proverbial trash can that others were about to condemn them to. Besides...truth be known...even most belt drive units have a speed adjustment lurking in a deep dark corner {near or on the motor itself} well hidden below their plinth's surfaces.
When considering a phono cartridge...one must also take into consideration tonearm mass. The higher massed S-shaped tonearms from Japan provide more damping than lower massed straight/J types that Dual introduced forty years ago. Some low cost entry belt driven types from Pioneer and Technics added even more damping to their heavier S-shaped arms by sporting a bit of friction in their bearings. Two such models that I owned from the late 70's were the Pioneer PL-112D and the Technics SL-B1.
Low tracking highly compliant cartridges were not an option in these yet they would sound just short of wonderful with an Empire {the prelude to Benz-Micro} Broadcast One that tracked at 2 to 2.5 grams. One could further maximize performance with Shure's M97EJ. Even a Stanton 500AL clocking in at 3.5 g's could sound pretty cool! The higher mass thus considerable damping mated well with stiffer stylus/cantilevers.
On the other hand...low massed Duals brought to life the more compliant Shures that tracked at low forces. These same cartridges would sound muddy at best in more massive arms. And so it only makes sense that the lower mass arm of the Technics would make for a brighter livelier quick sound somewhat similar to these ole Duals.
The Technics arm sports negligible bearing friction. Geometry is perfect as the Shure M97Xe's Two Point Stylus Protractor confirmed the Grado Black's squaring up quite nicely at both points!
Follow this link for a simple but wonderful explanation of proper tonearm/cartridge matching and damping...
http://www.gcaudio.com/resources/howtos/tonearmcartridge.html
The Grado's medium to low compliance and cartridge mass mates fairly well with the Technics and Grado suggests you use this pickup with a slightly laid back system like mine. The balance of sound in the end can be phenomenal on many recordings while being only less than fair on others!
The Almighty Ever-Revealing Listening Tests:
Right at about the twenty hour mark I heard the Black P open up and thus initial break in was complete. On sibilants the transducer did extremely well for a $28 cartridge although I believe my Perpetuum Ebner 3048/Shure M97xE deck to be better in this regard.
It did a creditable job on my Smokey Robinson And The Miracles "Away We A-Go-Go" album although the track "Save Me" gave it the slightest bit of trouble along with some others from the album. However...it edged out the M97xE on my Original Broadway Cast album of "The Sound Of Music" and absolutely aced the stereo recording of "My Fair Lady"...both CBS Masterworks.
Sibilance testing is an extremely important part of my evaluation and it must be said that it can make or break a particular phono pickup for me. When playing ELO's "Diary Of Horace Whimp"...a delightful but unusually dynamic tune that ends Side One of their "Discovery" LP on the CBS/Jet label...I immediately switched back to my reference PE 3048/Shure M97xE table to confirm what I was hearing!
The Grado Black P sounded downright harsh and awful on all of the sss-ss-sssounds which were absolutely smeared! The Shure M97xE to my surprise {but not to my delight or liking for that matter} didn't sound that much better but did manage to tame them a bit. Here is where I believe a much more expensive cartridge like the Shure V-15 V or Ortofon OM40 or even an old Pickering XSV-3000 will prove their worth.
The Black P's separation although very good at the beginning of play...tends to lessen along with its soundstaging as the stylus moves inward. This came as no surprise as other budget Grados of the past were just as guilty of this little quirk if not more so. My Ortofon OM40 Gold w/Van-Den-Hul stylus mounted in a Dual CS-515 ULM table remains the champ {at least in my mind} for this particular spec!
Then again...I know of few others that are as well balanced in their left and right channel outputs. It's one thing to boast wide separation but that means little if the two channels are not equal. Again...the Grado Black P is a champion in this regard telegraphing to me that the young ladies at the Brooklyn, N.Y.C. plant have done a remarkable job in the quality control dept.
The Soundstage presented by this model is very three-dimensional...very deep...and balanced! I guess I wasn't too surprised as high end stores absolutely insist that all of their products and manufacturers feature this sometimes omitted-by-mass-marketers but cherished by audiophiles characteristic .
The Black P nicely fills out the low and high end of the musical spectrum and keeps all players spread out before you in proper perspective instead of bumping them forward like the Shure M97xE does or back like the lower cost A-T's...e.g. "Red Ed" ESCMG29 sometimes do.
What did surprise me was the authoritive bass this cart projects with good detail but not the quickest. There is some hanging about but not bad...not bad at all! Neil Young's "On The Beach" Reprise LP features an acoustic song entitled "For The Turnstiles" that also features Neil either punching a rhythmic palm on his guitar or foot kicking a wood bass box. Both the Grado Black P and Shure M97xE reproduce it well but the Black P clearly gives it more gut feeling and emotion!
The deep bass ability of the Grado did not also mean Big Time Hum this time around. Are you surprised? Well...I am too but the combo worked nicely with the TEC TC-760LC Preamp and AudioSource AMP 100. The cart in general is extremely quiet even on unclean recordings and produces no surface noise whereas the Shure M97xE sometimes does. The cartridge's deep bass is balanced with a nice high end to boot that is not edgy but does tend to disappear toward the inner groove.
Distortion is extremely low for the most part. However...on Telarc's "Carmina" there is some noticeable compression although dynamics are very good indeed on most other material. The SL-D30/Black P is not as refined as the PE/M97xE combo. Still...there were times when I would switch back from my PE/Shure Reference System to the Technics/Grado combo just to brighten up things a bit. This pairing does indeed liven up the sound a bit although still very natural in the overall presentation of whatever source you choose.
I was disappointed in the Grado's inability to bring two suspect audiophile pressings I own to life. One was the 200 gram RCA/Polydor Guess Who's "American Woman" album that sounds only OK with the M97xE but best with the A-T 3482 and 92ECD while only fair to hashy with the Black P. The same could be said of the Sundazed 180 gram re-issue of Love's "Forever Changes" which fuses Rock, Acoustic and Classic altogether for one legendary stunning album. Here...my reference PE 3048/Shure M97xE table teamed up to emode all the emotion one could expect from a classic 1967 recording.
Tracking Ability is very good with only the slightest of groove chatter on a few recordings. Transients were handled well and quick with detail on Vangelis's RCA "Heaven And Hell" although again...my reference table and cartridge clearly outperformed it but Female Voices on all LP's were surprisingly great and I'm not sure any other competing manufacturer of cartridge at any price could manage them better!
Male voices were no less a forte' and John Grado has to be congratulated for making such a low cost unit sound so real, balanced and natural...especially on older recordings. The Grado has an uncanny ability to wake them from the dead.
The Bee Gees made a wonderful masterpiece back in 1969 known as "Odessa". The RSO Canadian complete 2 LP reissue features two orchestral pieces known as "Seven Seas Symphony" and "With All Nations {International Anthem}".
I have never heard the latter reproduced with more depth, detail and emotion. It is a phenomenal piece that is near and dear to me. The former features a classical piano that sounds absolutely stunningly real with the Grado Black P! I have yet to hear another cartridge that can equal the accuracy of the Grado on this one.
Warp tracking with the Technics arm was nothing short of superb! It is the only combo I presently own that can fully handle a very severely warped 1977 Miklos Rozsa/National Philharmonic Orchestra & Chorus recording...Music From The Film "Ben-Hur" on London SPC21166 that is very dynamic along with being extremely near and dear to me but was improperly stored by yours truly for a rather lengthy period of time and developed quite a high warp. I thought I'd never fully hear it again. The Grado plays it like the defect doesn't even exist! Therefore...it is a champion in this regard.
In Conclusion:
The balance and soundstaging is great almost to the end of play although I do notice a bit o' breakdown as noted in the report. I think that this can be improved when mounted in a good Linear Tracking Tonearm such as that of my shrouded Pioneer PL-L50 that lurks in a deep dark corner at the top of our china closet. When I finally solve the mystery of why it won't play...I'll fix it and report on the Grado mounted in the Pio with its Dynamic Anti-Resonance arm.
Another thing I would like to emphasize is that the Grado Prestige Black P-Mount Moving Iron Phono Cartridge is the first pickup I soley tested using this wonderful preamp from http://www.phonopreamps.com. I was perhaps a bit too critical at times during play because of the new sonic revelations made known to me through this improved system of mine.
My new found love in phono cartridges...Grado has shown me the light with the Audiosource/Polk amp/speaker combo and can literally shake the room without adding any tonal compensation...besides...I have none!
With the holidays just around the corner...it may be time to break out your old LP's and venture into that deep dark corner of your home to find {if you were fortunate enough NOT to sell it} that P-Mount turntable you forsakened years ago.
Whatever few shortcomings that can be attributed to this Prestige Black P are more than made up for by not only its low low price tag but by its sheer pleasant and most enjoyable musicality. It is the best P-Mount model currently available at the thirty dollar price tag. Bravo...Grado!...PJS Series II
Associated gear
AudioSource Amp 100
Pioneer TX-5500-II Tuner
TEC TC-760LC Audiophile Phono Preamp
Technics SL-D30 Direct Drive Turntable
Polk R-30 Towers
Kimber Kable Kwik-12 Speaker Interconnects
Similar products tested
Audio-Technica A-T 3482
A-T 92ECD
Shure M92E
Shure M94P
Shure V-15HRP
Stanton L720EE
Ortofon OMP3e
Stanton L847S
Pickering TLE
Recommended:
Yes
|
|
|
|
Epinions.com ID:
sam-pro
|
 - Top 500 |
|
Member: Peter J Sammon II
Location: The Bloomfield Burying Ground, USA
Reviews written: 218
Trusted by: 122 members
About Me:
Every once in awhile something great arrives at relatively low cost to you...Priceless!
|
|
|
- Add to My Yahoo!: 
- Add to Google Homepage: 
© 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc.